?

Log in

No account? Create an account
Everybody Dance Now!!
Pick a tune and let the DJ spin it...
What genre is to me... 
5th-Aug-2015 06:23 pm
Just me

I write genre. Why do I say this: because I write urban fantasy and horror. Thus, I’ve accepted that label… but am I right?


See, technically I think all fiction creates an alternate universe, no matter if it’s ‘realistic’ literary fiction, or SciFi, or urban fantasy, or whatever. However, at university literary fiction is not considered to be a genre and weirdly magical realism and speculative fiction are not really considered genre either… so when Margret Atwood penned ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ it is not considered to be science fiction by the literary community but the more acceptable speculative fiction. This is despite the fact that ‘The Handmaid’s Tale’ won Arthur C. Clark science fiction award as well as being nominated for two other prestigious ‘genre’ awards. I guess winning the Governor Generals Award (which is for literature) and being nominated for the Booker Prize means that it can’t be a lowly science fiction dystopia novel but something more special.


I do kind of get it… poorly written literary fiction gets ignored where as poorly written science fiction, fantasy, etc. can get a fan following of millions and spawn TV and movie franchises… not exactly fair.


The problem is, and I think where judgement starts to enter the argument, well-written literary fiction can be equally ignored. Why? Who truly knows. I mean Stephen King was unknown at one point in his life, what has made him so popular? But is it right to accuse me of having ‘lower standards’ because I prefer to read something that will scare the crap out of me or whisk me off to world with magic?


The answer is no. All books have value, whether I like them or not, and the only reason I think labels should be given is so I’m able find what I want to read easier. If that makes me a lowly genre writer/reader then I will wear that badge with pride.

Comments 
6th-Aug-2015 10:08 am (UTC)
where as poorly written science fiction, fantasy, etc. can get a fan following of millions and spawn TV and movie franchises

You forgot fantastic science fiction/fantasy that gets "butchered" (no pun intended) going from book to TV, like "The Dresden Files," by Jim Butcher. Ridiculously good books. Craptastic TV show. I am extremely glad the rights have reverted to Jim. Perhaps now we can get the show we deserve.
6th-Aug-2015 04:55 pm (UTC)
Absolutely!!! What the hell were they thinking!!! You can add Constantine to that list too... seriously, let's shove a six comic book series with complex characters and plot into 42 minutes and make sure none of the universe is explained to newbies... THEN change one of the loved characters from the comics into someone unappealing and unrecognizable so the fans of Constantine are alienated...

6th-Aug-2015 04:57 pm (UTC)
Just to add, in both cases I thought they had picked a perfect lead actor, which is even more of waste and makes me just that little bit more angry...
This page was loaded Oct 20th 2019, 6:30 am GMT.